Dec 29, 2025
Transformer Protection: From Electromechanical to Digital Relays
Transformers play a vital role in how substations distribute power to homes and businesses. They obviously need to be protected from a variety of faults that could otherwise damage their sensitive components. Engineers rely primarily on relays to do the job.
A relay is an electrical device with monitoring at its core. It continually monitors a variety of conditions, including current, voltage, and temperature. If an anomaly or fault is identified, the relay isolates the affected transformer from the rest of the system, preventing damage.
Decades ago, electromechanical relays dominated substation design. Today's numerical relays take advantage of microprocessor technology and digital signal processing to do the same job.
Electromechanical Relays: The Basics
An electromechanical relay is based on the principle of electromagnetic forces acting on surfaces. Those surfaces can include discs, armatures, and cups. When the current or voltage flowing through a relay exceeds the device's set threshold, activation occurs.
One of the main advantages of the electromechanical relay is its rugged nature. By design, electromechanical devices hold up well over extended periods of time. They are also fairly intuitive. On the negative side of things, electromechanical relays require more panel space along with individual wiring and manual changes. They require periodic maintenance to keep them operating properly.
It is also worth noting that electromechanical relays are not as fast as their numerical counterparts. They may not be as accurate or sensitive thanks to their mechanical tolerances and CT/VT limits.
Numerical Relays: The Basics
Numerical relays are microprocessor-based devices capable of digitizing analog currents and voltages. Sometimes referred to as IEDs, the relays combine microprocessors with software algorithms to provide protection, control, and ongoing monitoring in a single package.
The primary upside of the numerical relay is its accuracy. But there are other attractive benefits, including self-monitoring and self-diagnostic capabilities, event recording, built-in communication capabilities, and oscillography. The icing on the cake is that numerical relays are faster than their electromechanical counterparts.
Because they are microprocessor-based, they are highly programmable as well. A single numerical relay provides the same functionality that can only be achieved with multiple electromechanical relays and auxiliaries.
Engineers can deploy fewer physical components when choosing numerical relays. That means reduced wiring and fewer failure points. They also save panel space and eliminate the need for mechanical adjustments because all updates and setting changes are handled via software.
How They Protect Transformers
Electromechanical relays represent a more traditional way to protect transformers. The devices combine a limited set of functions, each of which is deployed in a separate device. Functions include:
Differential protection
Instantaneous and time overcurrent
Over/under-voltage
Thermal relays
The sensitivity and flexibility of electromechanical release are affected by CT/VT burdens and fixed characteristics. Any limit on the number of devices that can be installed in a given space requires proper coordination.
On the other hand, numerical relays can implement a much broader suite of protection elements to prevent transformer damage. The result is a more precise device offering multiple stages of protection along with better coordination and security.
Numerical Relays Are the Preferred Option
Although electromechanical relays have not yet been completely phased out, they are not nearly as popular as they once were. Substation designers now prefer numerical relays wherever they make sense. A numerical relay takes the best of established electromechanical principles and combines them with digital technologies to offer better protection.
From the consumer's point of view, the types of relays a substation engineer chooses are less important than the fact that the power remains on. Whichever way transformers are protected is fine with the average consumer.
Back to All Insights