Feb 12, 2026
Protective Relay Schemes: Safeguarding the Heart of the Grid
Summary: Protecting a substation against electrical faults is critical to ensuring its ongoing productivity. Engineers utilize a variety of essential protective relay schemes to prevent damage to transformers, busbars, and transmission lines.
As experts in substation engineering and design, we understand that a substation is only as reliable as the systems that protect it. In that sense, they are very similar to municipal water systems. If such a system were built with no emergency shutoff valves, a single line break would shut everything down. No one would have any water.
Likewise, a substation built with no protective systems would be an open invitation to disaster – even for a simple failure. So we implement our own version of the emergency shutoff valve: the circuit breaker. The brains behind modern circuit breakers are protective relays.
For both electrical engineers and project stakeholders, designing the right relaying schemes is critical. A proper scheme ensures that an otherwise catastrophic equipment failure amounts to nothing more than a localized blip on the screen. A properly designed and implemented scheme can save millions of dollars on equipment that is never damaged and loss of revenue from downtime that never occurs.
Transformers Must Be Protected
At the heart of the essential protective relay scheme is the understanding that transformers must be protected at all costs. Transformers are a utility’s most valuable assets. They are also the most expensive pieces of equipment in any substation. Replacing a bad transformer is an expensive and time-consuming proposition. So protecting transformers is a priority.
The Differential Protection scheme (87T) is considered the gold standard for transformer protection. Think of it in terms of a scale. The amount of current going into and coming out of a transformer should remain balanced (accounting for the turns ratio). An unbalanced scenario suggests a leak somewhere in the transformer. This could be a short circuit. In order to protect the transformer, a relay will trip the circuit breaker within milliseconds of the imbalance being detected.
Differential protection works extremely well for internal leaks. It is not so helpful for protecting against overcurrent. For that, we need something that acts like a surge protector. That is where the Overcurrent Protection scheme (50/51) comes into play.
Overcurrent protection monitors for current spikes caused by something external. Think of a downed power line. It kicks in to prevent a transformer from overheating while trying to feed a fault beyond its capacity.
Busbars Must Also Be Protected
Busbars are as valuable to electrical substations as transformers are . A busbar is a connection point where all a substation’s lines meet. Consider it as a substation’s Grand Central Station, if you will. Here is the challenge: thanks to so many lines coming together at a single connection point, a single fault on a busbar can be quite dangerous. If it is not quickly cleared, it can shut down every single line in the substation.
Busbars are typically protected via the Bus Differential scheme (87B). This scheme monitors every connection point on the busbar. It measures incoming current and compares it against the outgoing. If the numbers do not match, a fault is assumed. The bus is cleared by opening every breaker.
The scheme can be designed to accommodate both high and low impedance:
High Impedance – High impedance is a traditional and very fast method for clearing buses. But to make it work, all the transformer sensors in the system must be identical.
Low Impedance – A low impedance system is a more modern system that relies on a digital approach. It is more flexible and capable of handling different types of sensors. It’s ideal for complex substations.
Strong busbar protection prevents catastrophic failures that could shut down an entire substation within seconds. Likewise, properly protecting busbars adds an additional layer of protection for the transformers.
Protecting the Transmission Lines
While transformers are the most expensive assets and busbars the most complex, the most vulnerable assets in the system are transmission lines. They are miles long and exposed to an endless array of environmental and manmade influences. Electrical engineers rely on two types of protection to keep transmission lines up and running.
The first is the Distance Protection scheme (21). It uses distance relaying to measure both voltage and current by way of Ohm’s Law. It is a very clever way to determine where a fault exists. For example, if a relay calculates a fault at just five miles on a line that is twenty miles long, it trips the line immediately. But if the fault is detected at fifty miles, it exists on a neighboring line.
The Line Differential scheme (87L) relies on a communication link between both ends of the line. The relays at either end communicate constantly to compare currents. If their numbers don’t match, both relays will instantly trip. Line Differential protection is the fastest and most secure form of transmission line protection.
Best Practices Keep Everything Up and Running
With so many protective relay schemes to work with, engineers have a lot of tools for keeping transformers, busbars, and transmission lines up and running. But it is important that they follow industry best practices. Those best practices include:
Redundancy – Redundancy is non-negotiable. Every major piece of equipment must be protected with both a primary and a secondary relay. The two relays are often from separate manufacturers to eliminate the risk of software bugs affecting both systems.
Selectivity – Schemes must be designed so that only the necessary equipment is tripped to clear a fault. For example, there is no need to shut down an entire substation because a single line in a local neighborhood was felled by a tree.
Speed – Protection schemes must be fast enough to accommodate high-voltage systems. Tripping a system in just half-a-second, as opposed to a full second, could mean the difference between minor damage and a catastrophic failure.
Electrical substations are highly sensitive environments subject to a variety of faults. Keeping everything in order while minimizing risks to equipment and productivity is a job best left to essential protective relay schemes. When implemented properly, consumers on the other end of the grid are none the wiser. That’s the way it should be.
FAQs
What is a relay in a modern substation?
Modern relays are miniature computers with sensors that continually monitor power system health. They send signals to circuit breakers when faults are detected.
What are the numbers associated with the various relay schemes?
They are ANSI Device Numbers. We use them as a sort of shorthand to describe what a particular device does.
How are relays updated?
Relays can be updated locally, but they are more likely to be updated remotely. They are connected to a network engineers can access without having to drive to the physical substation.
Are relays routinely tested?
Utilities test their relays to make sure everything is in working order. A schedule of 2 to 6 years is pretty typical. More critical stations will be tested more frequently.
Are relays affected by lightning?
Relays can be affected by lightning. However, they detect lightning strikes and trip breakers when necessary.
What happens if a relay fails?
Modern systems are built with the necessary redundancy. If one relay fails, the backup kicks in.
Back to All Insights